Scabies Treatment Selector
Your Treatment Recommendation
Select your circumstances to get a personalized recommendation
Answer a few questions
How It Works
This tool recommends the most appropriate scabies treatment based on your specific circumstances. Each treatment has different effectiveness rates, safety profiles, and cost considerations. We've incorporated clinical guidelines from recent studies to ensure evidence-based recommendations.
When it comes to treating scabies, Elimite is a topical cream that delivers 5% permethrin and has become the go‑to option for many clinicians. Yet the market also offers oral ivermectin, benzyl benzoate lotion, sulfur ointment, and even a few natural extracts. If you’ve ever wondered whether Elimite truly outperforms these alternatives, this guide walks you through the science, the costs, and the practical tips you need to pick the right product for your case.
Why Permethrin Still Rules the Roost
Permethrin belongs to the pyrethroid class of insecticides. It works by disrupting the sodium channels in the nerve cells of the scabies mite Sarcoptes scabiei, causing paralysis and death within minutes. Clinical trials from 2022‑2024 report cure rates of 92‑98% after a single 8‑hour application, making it the most effective single‑dose topical therapy available.
Top Alternatives on the Market
Below is a snapshot of the main contenders you’ll encounter in Australian pharmacies and online stores.
- Ivermectin - an oral antiparasitic taken as a single dose (or two doses a week apart) that targets the mite’s neurotransmission.
- Benzyl benzoate - a oily lotion applied overnight for three consecutive nights; it acts as a neurotoxin.
- Sulfur ointment - a 5‑10% preparation traditionally used for infants; it suffocates the mite.
- Tea tree oil - a natural essential oil with reported acaricidal properties, typically blended at 5‑10% in a carrier.
Side‑Effect Profiles You Should Mind
Every treatment carries its own risk set. Here’s a quick rundown:
- Elimite (permethrin) - mild skin irritation, itching, or a temporary burning sensation in about 5% of users.
- Ivermectin - rare nausea, dizziness, or headache; contraindicated in patients with severe liver disease.
- Benzyl benzoate - strong odor and potential skin redness; can irritate eczema‑prone skin.
- Sulfur ointment - greasy texture and a distinct smell; may cause mild dermatitis in sensitive individuals.
- Tea tree oil - occasional allergic contact dermatitis when applied undiluted.
Cost and Accessibility in Australia (2025)
Price matters, especially if you need to treat an entire household.
| Product | Typical Dose | Average Price | Availability |
|---|---|---|---|
| Elimite (5% permethrin cream) | 15g tube - one application | 38.00 | Pharmacies, online Rx |
| Ivermectin 12mg tablets | 2×12mg (single dose) | 45.00 | Prescription only |
| Benzyl benzoate 25% lotion | 30ml - three nightly applications | 22.00 | OTC in pharmacies |
| Sulfur ointment 5% | 30g - nightly for 3days | 18.00 | Pharmacies, some supermarkets |
| Tea tree oil 10% blend | 15ml - twice daily for 5days | 30.00 | Health food stores, online |
How to Choose the Right Option for You
Here’s a decision‑making flow that aligns the drug’s characteristics with common patient scenarios:
- Severity and spread: If the infestation covers large areas or involves crusted scabies, combine oral ivermectin with topical permethrin for higher clearance.
- Age and skin condition: For infants under 2months or people with eczema, sulfur ointment or a diluted tea tree oil blend is gentler.
- Pregnancy or breastfeeding: Permethrin is classified as Category B (low risk), while oral ivermectin is usually avoided unless benefits outweigh risks.
- Allergies and sensitivities: Patients with known pyrethroid allergy should skip permethrin and opt for benzyl benzoate or a non‑chemical alternative.
- Cost constraints: Sulfur ointment offers the cheapest effective route, but may require longer treatment duration.
By matching your circumstances to these criteria, you can avoid trial‑and‑error and get faster relief.
Practical Tips for Effective Application
- Wash the entire body with warm water and mild soap 12hours before applying any topical.
- Apply the cream or lotion from the neck down, then extend to the scalp, face, and soles of the feet.
- Leave Elimite on for exactly 8hours (overnight is easiest) before washing off.
- For benzyl benzoate, wear old clothing and use a disposable towel to avoid staining.
- When using sulfur, apply a thin layer and cover with a light bandage to keep it in place.
When to Seek Professional Help
If you notice any of the following, book an appointment promptly:
- Persistent itching after two weeks of treatment.
- Development of secondary bacterial infection (redness, pus, fever).
- Signs of crusted scabies-thick, scaly plaques that don’t respond to standard doses.
- Allergic reaction like widespread rash or swelling.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I use Elimite on children under 2 months?
No. Permethrin is not approved for infants younger than 2months. Sulfur ointment or a pediatric‑dose ivermectin (under specialist guidance) are safer options.
Is a single dose of ivermectin enough?
For classic scabies, a single 200µg/kg dose works for most adults, but a second dose 7‑10 days later is recommended to catch any newly hatched mites.
Why does the itching continue after treatment?
The mite’s debris can trigger an allergic reaction that lasts weeks after the parasites are dead. Antihistamines or topical steroids can help control the itch.
Are there any drug interactions with ivermectin?
Ivermectin is metabolized by CYP3A4, so strong inhibitors (e.g., ketoconazole) may raise blood levels. Always disclose all current medications to your doctor.
Can tea tree oil replace prescription meds?
Evidence is limited to small case series. It may help mild infestations, but for reliable cure rates, prescription‑strength permethrin or ivermectin remain the gold standard.
Bottom line: Elimite leads the pack for quick, high‑success treatment, but cost, age, pregnancy, and skin sensitivity can tilt the scales toward oral ivermectin, benzyl benzoate, sulfur, or a carefully chosen natural option. Use the comparison table and decision checklist to match the therapy to your life, and you’ll be itching‑free faster.
